Thursday, December 30, 2010

Winter's Grit: These Boots Are Made For Walking


As I sat in the theater watching the latest Coen brother's film, True Grit, I quickly noticed a certain familiarity with the character of Mattie Ross (Hailee Steinfeld). The film's main focus, Mattie is an intelligent and determined 14-year-old girl who will stop at nothing when it comes to finding the man that murdered her father in cold blood. This young female character immediately brought me to thoughts of Ree Dolly (Jennifer Lawrence), the lead protagonist in Debra Granik's incredible film, Winter's Bone. Much like Mattie, Ree is a smart and unwavering female character that also has a difficult task that she is faced with. But as opposed to finding her father's killer, Ree is trying to find her father - who may or may not even be alive – so she can save her family from an uncertain fate.

truegrit1Two very different women that both share a single goal, armed with a drive that would dwarf even the largest of obstacles. Mattie and Ree are inspiringly strong female characters who share many qualities despite their cultural differences. They are what you could call survivors in a way, but one is forced to do so out of necessity, while the other does so to see that justice is served for the one that she has lost. Both have what I would like to call true courage, though, in Mattie's case, she may be too young and naïve to see the danger in which she is putting herself. Then again, maybe she does in fact see it and simply doesn't let it topple her strong spirit. Ree, on the other hand, has to have courage. She has to because if she doesn't, not only will it affect her, but her defenseless family, too.


Even at the age of 17, Ree is already a world-weary woman due to living a very difficult and hardening life. She is not well educated, but her smarts come from the survival instincts formed by living in the very difficult world that she was born into. She has grown up in a place where it is a necessity to endure, and she is using that strength to fight tooth and nail to keep from losing her home. A home that would be lost if her bail-jumping meth-cooking father isn't found. This isn't a story about a girl trying to find her father to save him. Instead, it is about a girl that will risk her life in a dangerous world (that many of us are not at all familiar with), not to keep a roof over her head, but the head of Ree's two younger siblings and ill mother. In this situation, Ree has become the mother, the one that has the ability to take charge and keep her family from situations that no one should ever have to be confronted with. Including herself.


Mattie has a lot more going for her as far as a future goes. An incredibly quick witted and sharp young lady, she has the ability to make things happen with her tenacity for verbal deliberation. She is so young, which makes it easy to underestimate her but it's also something that works to her advantage when she is able to get the best of unsuspecting adults. She understands laws, she understands her rights, and has no problem with letting people know that she will not be easily pushed around. She rides down a road that is never made any less difficult for her due to her age or sexuality, but it is just those qualities that seem to feed her aggressive posture, making her a stronger force because of it. She is driven by despair for a father that was wrongfully taken from her and will stop at nothing to see that his killer pays for his crime.

winter'sbone2What Mattie and Ree share as characters is simply how resilient they are to the oppression that faces them. There is no wall that either of these "girls" cannot scale because their drive is too intense, too important. These are fantastically written characters and are brought to life by equally amazing performances. In a movie where Jeff Bridges shows just why he won an Oscar, Hailee Steinfeld is able to stand out in what is a wonderful performance for such a young girl. In fact, it may even be good enough for an Oscar nod, in my opinion. As far as Jennifer Lawrence goes, well, lets just say that in a world where someone like Sandra Bullock can win a sympathy Oscar for playing a hallow character, then it would be a travesty if Lawrence wasn't granted the shot to win for a character and performance that truly should be applauded.


  1. Excellent comparative analysis, Matt. I've yet to see True Grit and am hoping to remedy that next weekend, but Winter's Bone is very likely my choice for film of the year.

    We've seen so much film and literature that turns fatherless daughters into these tragic victims who "search for love in all the wrong places" as the old saying goes. So it's nice to see some young female performances that demonstrate strong character traits that are, in some ways, every bit as masculine as those a father figure might have provided.

  2. Great stuff! I also echo karl's thoughts. I love that there's no need for a love interest in either film. Both roles are simply great, and performed amazingly.

  3. I was really impressed with Hailee Steinfeld's performance as well. That was actually my favorite part of the movie. I haven't seen Winter's Bone and I'll have to check that out.

  4. True Grit = awesome. WInter's Bone = unseen.

  5. I still need to see both of these. This month has been a bitch.
    I love this post!!

  6. Karl: Thanks, man! It’s true and unfortunate that more female characters aren’t written this way, but it is nice to have two films within the same year come out and avoid pandering to lame stereotypes that have very little basis in most women.

    Even better is both films come from totally different places and are getting their respective recognition, which I think is most important with Winter’s Bone as its story is an important one for cinema.

    Emily: If there were even the slightest touch of love story thrown in, it would have completely soured either of the movies. Neither girl needed to be metaphysically saved by a man, and I think it was refreshing that Mattie’s character never developed any sort of father daughter relationship with Coogan. That’s not what she needed.

    Becky: Yeah, I thought all of the performances were incredible, but she specifically stood out, which is due to her performance as well as how great her character was written. She quickly won me over and makes a great film an even better film. And see Winter’s Bone!

    Simon and Christine: You both really need to rectify that immediately! It’s a slow moving film that’s sole focus is on the characters and the look into the world they live in, specifically and most importantly, Ree, the film’s main character. I would love to know both of your thoughts on it, fo sho.

  7. I've not seen either film as yet, but looking forward to getting to do so. I'm not sure either is released in the UK yet.

    I'm also a big fan of the absence of unnecessary romantic sub plots. They are my pet hate in movies.

  8. I cannot believe how they can find a way into so many movies. Like, even a film that does not in any way warrant one, there will be one that just comes from out of nowhere. It can really sour a great film, and for what? To try and draw in a romantic audience? Whatever. Thanks for the comment, Dan, and I hope you get to see both films soon!


Most Popular Posts

Chuck Norris Ate My Baby is in no way endorsed by or affiliated with Chuck Norris the Actor.